8
votes
Accepted
I'm British should I stop flagging?
There is a difference between Declined flags and Disputed flags. When a flag is disputed, nothing more happens, it just disappears into the void. You can never be banned for disputed flags.
The more ...
PieBieMod
- 4,328
8
votes
Accepted
Why was my comment of helpful resources removed?
I was the one who deleted it. Your exact comment was:
The core approach is firing an animation using either the intersection observer API or simply the scroll position of the page. A good article ...
PieBieMod
- 4,328
6
votes
I'm British should I stop flagging?
Further to this, what happens if mods decide they don't like you because you've challenged them and their thinking?
If you think a mod is doing that speak up so the other mods can take a look or you ...
- 23k
5
votes
Accepted
Moderating criteria, acording to the moderating criteria
The linked question is way too broad. Even if you remove the "best" aspect, we still do not want to encourage these types of "list" questions that could never definitively be answered.
Assuming ...
- 19.9k
4
votes
Moderating criteria, acording to the moderating criteria
A good tool to visually design graphical user interfaces for iOS devices?
Which graphic design application should I learn after Photoshop and Illustrator?
Recommendations for designing tiled maps
...
- 204k
4
votes
Inconsistency in question closing moderation
Close voting being inconsistent is no more than logical--it's humans who do it. Beyond that, it is the actual community that does the voting, and who actually votes on what questions is rarely, if ...
- 25k
3
votes
Inconsistency in question closing moderation
Our moderation is simply inconsistent because there are too few people voting. You see, in every topic there are several opinions about how it should be moderated. In one of the sites where theres lot ...
- 56.8k
3
votes
Inconsistency in question closing moderation
Wall of text warning.
I figure I'll post my opinion on this since I voted on both of those questions (and inconsistently) and I'll preface this by saying the obvious: close votes are essentially ...
- 10.9k
3
votes
Moderating criteria, acording to the moderating criteria
I think you're missing the purpose of the SE model and that is a well formulated question that can in fact be answered. That said those questions will never have an answer that will serve:
1) ...
- 18.3k
2
votes
Inconsistency in question closing moderation
Generally speaking, the best way to handle these issues for a particular set of questions is to bring it up here on meta or in the GD chat. So well done!
As for your particular question, I voted to ...
- 13.2k
1
vote
Inconsistency in question closing moderation
In reviewing the history of the Gotham question which is open the final tally was
Feb 18 '15 at 3:04 review close
Feb 23 '15 at 16:56 completed Leave Open × 3, Close × 2
5 members ...
- 23k
1
vote
Moderating criteria, acording to the moderating criteria
Regarding "best"
It is my observation, and thus opinion, that best software/technique questions are questions that only have opinionated answers. Reason being that:
Only best a person can ...
- 56.8k
1
vote
Moderating criteria, acording to the moderating criteria
Not exactly an answer to your question, but a counter question to make you think:
Should we be forced to keep a question that violates our scope, guidelines or requirements, just because you answered ...
- 8,328
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible