I've noticed a few equipment purchasing questions on this site. Do questions related to choosing equipment belong here?

What is a good scanner on a budget?

What image tablet can you recommend on a budget?

2 Answers 2


I'd say they are on-topic if they're used in on-topic context; and same should go also for software recommendations.

  • 7
    I would also add that the author has to get really, really specific about the problem they are trying to solve. Questions ask simply "What tablet should I buy" should be closed as not a real question. They are too vague to answer reasonably. Jan 5, 2011 at 21:24

I'd say:

  • Software recommendations are fine, both free and commercial

  • Instead of hardware purchase recommendations, we should generally strive to provide generic guides to identifying a suitable device for the OP's needs. What attributes to look for; what price range to prepare for; what kind of place sells them at what kind of price; and so on. Purchase guidelines don't age as quickly as shopping recommendations do, and it's still possible to point out some actual devices in the text.

Exceptions should be

  • hardware recommendations based on own personal experience ("I've been using the X-B10 for three years now and ....") which in my opinion have inherent value if written by a honest and competent person

  • specialized tools for which there is no big market of choices.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .