Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackDesign/status/578308185297186816
clarified title a bit - it makes no sense to answer "program specific questions" with another software
Link
Takkat
  • 12.6k
  • 12
  • 5

Answering program specific questions with solutions from alternative software if solutions are not specific to a given program

Corrected English, added relevant tag, made title more understandable
Source Link
Zach Saucier
  • 13.4k
  • 14
  • 19

Is is welcome to answer Answering program specific questions tagged "Photoshop" or "Illustrator" with solutions from alternative software?

Sometimes I come across questions on general issues with using graphics software that are tagged or, , or mention these applciations in the question body but, However, solutions to the issue may be indenticalidentical on many alternative applications, namely Open Sourceopen source counterparts like oror , or even command line applications such as .

In the past I refrainhave refrained from answering if a question appears to be specific for Adopbe products, andto Adobe products; it seems an answer regarding other software would make little sense. This is not always the case. RarelyOccasionally, an alternative may even give better results or procedures involved arebe faster at doing the issue specified.

Quite often, steps involved for getting any desired result differ only in the names of the tools but not so much in the procedures involved. In these cases, I sometimes still write an answer but I always feel a bit uncomfortable about it as the OP may be looking for Photoshop/Illustrator solutions only.

Is thisAm I welcome to do this? Are there circumstances where adding an additional tag to the question may be a good idea (I never did thathaven't done this so far)?

Is is welcome to answer questions tagged "Photoshop" or "Illustrator" with solutions from alternative software?

Sometimes I come across questions on general issues with using graphics software that are tagged or or mention these applciations in the question body but solutions to the issue may be indentical on many alternative applications namely Open Source counterparts or or even command line applications such as .

In the past I refrain from answering if a question appears to be specific for Adopbe products, and an answer regarding other software would make little sense. This is not always the case. Rarely an alternative may even give better results or procedures involved are faster.

Quite often steps involved for getting any desired result differ only in the names of the tools but not so much in procedures involved. In these cases I sometimes still write an answer but I always feel a bit uncomfortable about it as the OP may be looking for Photoshop/Illustrator solutions only.

Is this welcome to do? Are there circumstances where adding an additional tag to the question may be a good idea (I never did that so far)?

Answering program specific questions with solutions from alternative software

Sometimes I come across questions on general issues with using graphics software that are tagged , , or mention these applciations in the question body, However, solutions to the issue may be identical on many alternative applications, namely open source counterparts like or , or even command line applications such as .

In the past I have refrained from answering if a question appears to be specific to Adobe products; it seems an answer regarding other software would make little sense. This is not always the case. Occasionally, an alternative may even give better results or be faster at doing the issue specified.

Quite often, steps involved for getting any desired result differ only in the names of the tools but not so much in the procedures involved. In these cases, I sometimes still write an answer but I always feel a bit uncomfortable about it as the OP may be looking for Photoshop/Illustrator solutions only.

Am I welcome to do this? Are there circumstances where adding an additional tag to the question may be a good idea (I haven't done this so far)?

Source Link
Takkat
  • 12.6k
  • 12
  • 5

Is is welcome to answer questions tagged "Photoshop" or "Illustrator" with solutions from alternative software?

Sometimes I come across questions on general issues with using graphics software that are tagged or or mention these applciations in the question body but solutions to the issue may be indentical on many alternative applications namely Open Source counterparts or or even command line applications such as .

In the past I refrain from answering if a question appears to be specific for Adopbe products, and an answer regarding other software would make little sense. This is not always the case. Rarely an alternative may even give better results or procedures involved are faster.

Quite often steps involved for getting any desired result differ only in the names of the tools but not so much in procedures involved. In these cases I sometimes still write an answer but I always feel a bit uncomfortable about it as the OP may be looking for Photoshop/Illustrator solutions only.

Is this welcome to do? Are there circumstances where adding an additional tag to the question may be a good idea (I never did that so far)?